Gunmarks
4FG
[4FG]

4FunGamers

EU

“Sytuacja jest prosta!”

Commander: kokster12395 membersFounded 9 Jan 2016
Average WN8: GoodInvite only

Roster as of 7 Nov 2026 · 3 hours ago

Compare

About

Warunki dołączenia do klanu:
– T95/FV4201 Chieftain
– Mile widziane 279e, 907, CS 63 (jak nie masz Chieftaina to na tych czołgach musisz dobrze grać)
– DPG na X drzewkowych 3k+, na specjalnych 3,7k+
– https://discord.gg/7hr4JwDzeP


Liczba zdobytych czołgów:
Ognisty Szlak - 42 licencje
Narodziny Przemysłu - 33 licencje,
Metalowe Wojny - 51 licencji, 58 miejsce
Renesans - 65 licencji, 98 miejsce
Burza - 61 licencji, 26 miejsce
Konfrontacja - 39 licencji, 24 miejsce
Epoka żelaza - 57 licencji, 7 miejsce klanu

Founder
kokster123
Clan id
500070968
Followed here since
14 Oct 2026

History

150 most recent events

6 Nov 2026

  • Accepted Members

    6 Nov 2026, 14:58 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Paleczuwka has been accepted to the clan.

15 Oct 2026

  • Accepted Members

    15 Oct 2026, 19:52 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player balbes_balbesovich1 has been accepted to the clan.

4 Oct 2026

  • Accepted Members

    4 Oct 2026, 18:23 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player matrix123_67 has been accepted to the clan.

23 Sept 2026

  • Accepted Members

    23 Sept 2026, 20:34 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player LopezPL has been accepted to the clan.

17 Sept 2026

  • Accepted Members

    17 Sept 2026, 21:26 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player ELantek_2017 has been accepted to the clan.

6 Sept 2026

  • Accepted Members

    6 Sept 2026, 18:18 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player pluzin has been accepted to the clan.

31 Aug 2026

  • Members Left

    31 Aug 2026, 16:52 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player MistrzMarcin left the clan.

24 Aug 2026

  • Accepted Members

    24 Aug 2026, 11:08 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player 67pozdroxdtakpoprostu has been accepted to the clan.

22 Aug 2026

  • Accepted Members

    22 Aug 2026, 18:55 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Dementh0r has been accepted to the clan.

12 Jul 2026

  • Accepted Members

    12 Jul 2026, 17:05 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player zombieshooter2 has been accepted to the clan.

11 Jul 2026

  • Accepted Members

    11 Jul 2026, 20:35 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player kokodaB620 has been accepted to the clan.

11 Jun 2026

  • Accepted Members

    11 Jun 2026, 18:41 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player barturek has been accepted to the clan.

26 Apr 2026

  • Accepted Members

    26 Apr 2026, 19:09 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player grzela76 has been accepted to the clan.

23 Apr 2026

  • Accepted Members

    23 Apr 2026, 18:50 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player gietek_2015 has been accepted to the clan.

18 Apr 2026

  • Accepted Members

    18 Apr 2026, 22:14 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player ksoma23 has been accepted to the clan.

9 Mar 2026

  • Accepted Members

    9 Mar 2026, 20:57 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player canek___ has been accepted to the clan.

24 Feb 2026

  • Accepted Members

    24 Feb 2026, 21:35 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Miodziu312 has been accepted to the clan.

21 Feb 2026

  • Accepted Members

    21 Feb 2026, 21:58 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Krzysiek_xb has been accepted to the clan.

  • Accepted Members

    21 Feb 2026, 21:51 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player azaz3l_13 has been accepted to the clan.

15 Feb 2026

  • Accepted Members

    15 Feb 2026, 16:59 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Zyga125 has been accepted to the clan.

6 Feb 2026

  • Accepted Members

    6 Feb 2026, 14:43 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player NinjaTank2013 has been accepted to the clan.

31 Jan 2026

  • Accepted Members

    31 Jan 2026, 18:32 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player uoxlpv has been accepted to the clan.

2 Jan 2026

  • Accepted Members

    2 Jan 2026, 17:32 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player KillerEmil_91 has been accepted to the clan.

25 Dec 2025

  • Accepted Members

    25 Dec 2025, 19:55 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player BL4CK_V3NOM has been accepted to the clan.

17 Dec 2025

  • Accepted Members

    17 Dec 2025, 13:35 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player renamed_528056177 has been accepted to the clan.

16 Dec 2025

  • Accepted Members

    16 Dec 2025, 10:34 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player piotr00_1 has been accepted to the clan.

15 Dec 2025

  • Accepted Members

    15 Dec 2025, 18:54 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player doomeed has been accepted to the clan.

9 Dec 2025

  • Accepted Members

    9 Dec 2025, 20:06 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player killerdavid_2016 has been accepted to the clan.

8 Dec 2025

  • Accepted Members

    8 Dec 2025, 11:57 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Skagull666 has been accepted to the clan.

7 Dec 2025

  • Accepted Members

    7 Dec 2025, 15:52 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player damianq321 has been accepted to the clan.

5 Dec 2025

  • Accepted Members

    5 Dec 2025, 18:51 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player megis2s has been accepted to the clan.

  • Accepted Members

    5 Dec 2025, 17:11 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Matsllow has been accepted to the clan.

3 Dec 2025

  • Accepted Members

    3 Dec 2025, 21:27 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player chilunek has been accepted to the clan.

2 Dec 2025

  • Accepted Members

    2 Dec 2025, 12:55 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player MistrzMarcin has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

30 Nov 2025

  • Accepted Members

    30 Nov 2025, 22:30 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player ErwinRomelO7 has been accepted to the clan.

28 Nov 2025

  • Accepted Members

    28 Nov 2025, 20:31 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Dimon___tankist has been accepted to the clan.

27 Nov 2025

  • Accepted Members

    27 Nov 2025, 22:41 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Graf_anatolih_15 has been accepted to the clan.

  • Accepted Members

    27 Nov 2025, 21:26 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Ziolek_AT has been accepted to the clan.

16 Nov 2025

  • Accepted Members

    16 Nov 2025, 07:38 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Jurgeneczek has been accepted to the clan.

9 Nov 2025

  • Accepted Members

    9 Nov 2025, 14:52 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Melman45 has been accepted to the clan.

8 Nov 2025

  • Accepted Members

    8 Nov 2025, 22:16 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player SK0BKA has been accepted to the clan.

11 Sept 2025

  • Accepted Members

    11 Sept 2025, 18:16 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player sebunia1297 has been accepted to the clan.

10 Sept 2025

  • Accepted Members

    10 Sept 2025, 20:00 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Likwidator41 has been accepted to the clan.

31 Aug 2025

  • Accepted Members

    31 Aug 2025, 12:06 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Shuuuuuuuh has been accepted to the clan.

25 Aug 2025

  • Accepted Members

    25 Aug 2025, 20:34 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player hubertadd has been accepted to the clan.

  • Accepted Members

    25 Aug 2025, 08:52 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player DideQ_2 has been accepted to the clan.

24 Aug 2025

  • Accepted Members

    24 Aug 2025, 12:13 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player BlackMk_ has been accepted to the clan.

6 Aug 2025

  • Members Left

    6 Aug 2025, 18:51 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player wiejskiemleko left the clan.

30 Jul 2025

  • Accepted Members

    30 Jul 2025, 16:33 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player lampart07 has been accepted to the clan.

19 Jun 2025

  • Accepted Members

    19 Jun 2025, 20:15 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Aikon_PL has been accepted to the clan.

24 May 2025

  • Accepted Members

    24 May 2025, 17:21 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player peem2 has been accepted to the clan.

14 Apr 2025

  • Accepted Members

    14 Apr 2025, 16:17 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player komandos101 has been accepted to the clan.

1 Apr 2025

  • Accepted Members

    1 Apr 2025, 19:21 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player elobombelo_2014 has been accepted to the clan.

16 Mar 2025

  • Accepted Members

    16 Mar 2025, 15:41 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player iceman1983 has been accepted to the clan.

13 Mar 2025

  • Accepted Members

    13 Mar 2025, 17:48 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Wiktorynka has been accepted to the clan.

17 Feb 2025

  • Accepted Members

    17 Feb 2025, 18:53 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player EGZ1ST_ has been accepted to the clan.

2 Feb 2025

  • Accepted Members

    2 Feb 2025, 20:41 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player wiejskiemleko has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

25 Jan 2025

  • Accepted Members

    25 Jan 2025, 18:18 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player SchweineFleischMoerser has been accepted to the clan.

22 Jan 2025

  • Accepted Members

    22 Jan 2025, 21:13 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player KaWaii_DolKi has been accepted to the clan.

9 Jan 2025

  • Accepted Members

    9 Jan 2025, 13:32 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player MetalzZ48 has been accepted to the clan.

6 Jan 2025

  • Accepted Members

    6 Jan 2025, 18:21 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player TyniAss has been accepted to the clan.

19 Dec 2024

  • Accepted Members

    19 Dec 2024, 18:56 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player KaWaii_Bouli has been accepted to the clan.

10 Nov 2024

  • Accepted Members

    10 Nov 2024, 19:37 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player NaczelnyTata has been accepted to the clan.

7 Nov 2024

  • Accepted Members

    7 Nov 2024, 18:23 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Mateuszz2007 has been accepted to the clan.

  • Accepted Members

    7 Nov 2024, 18:03 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Dave_EBR_Enjoyer has been accepted to the clan.

22 Jun 2024

  • Accepted Members

    22 Jun 2024, 20:34 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player rafilix has been accepted to the clan.

9 May 2024

  • Members Left

    9 May 2024, 19:39 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player pokec000 left the clan.

6 Apr 2024

  • Accepted Members

    6 Apr 2024, 20:14 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _TaNkBaNk_ has been accepted to the clan.

31 Mar 2024

  • Accepted Members

    31 Mar 2024, 21:16 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Strajker3322 has been accepted to the clan.

27 Mar 2024

  • Accepted Members

    27 Mar 2024, 18:33 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player __Universal_soldier has been accepted to the clan.

24 Mar 2024

  • Accepted Members

    24 Mar 2024, 21:39 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _Guyver_S has been accepted to the clan.

  • Accepted Members

    24 Mar 2024, 15:59 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Dawedef has been accepted to the clan.

19 Mar 2024

  • Accepted Members

    19 Mar 2024, 22:04 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player renamed_514224059 has been accepted to the clan.

18 Mar 2024

  • Accepted Members

    18 Mar 2024, 17:32 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player takla_katan853 has been accepted to the clan.

16 Mar 2024

  • Accepted Members

    16 Mar 2024, 18:29 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Red_Cersei has been accepted to the clan.

  • Accepted Members

    16 Mar 2024, 14:07 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player LuKaDOOM has been accepted to the clan.

14 Mar 2024

  • Accepted Members

    14 Mar 2024, 16:07 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player clixxx90 has been accepted to the clan.

9 Mar 2024

  • Members Left

    9 Mar 2024, 22:34 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player wiejskiemleko left the clan.

31 Dec 2023

  • Accepted Members

    31 Dec 2023, 15:46 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _DIESEL_001 has been accepted to the clan.

22 Dec 2023

  • Accepted Members

    22 Dec 2023, 13:23 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Naub24 has been accepted to the clan.

18 Dec 2023

  • Accepted Members

    18 Dec 2023, 18:03 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player R_O_B_D_R_O_B has been accepted to the clan.

17 Dec 2023

  • Accepted Members

    17 Dec 2023, 12:12 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player xwhitexx has been accepted to the clan.

14 Dec 2023

  • Accepted Members

    14 Dec 2023, 20:08 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player pokec000 has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

  • Accepted Members

    14 Dec 2023, 14:56 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player OttovanHelweg has been accepted to the clan.

11 Dec 2023

  • Accepted Members

    11 Dec 2023, 21:26 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Maecksimus has been accepted to the clan.

10 Dec 2023

  • Accepted Members

    10 Dec 2023, 15:06 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player xSTARGARDx has been accepted to the clan.

9 Dec 2023

  • Accepted Members

    9 Dec 2023, 10:48 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player EGI5 has been accepted to the clan.

5 Dec 2023

  • Accepted Members

    5 Dec 2023, 18:35 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player wiejskiemleko has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

20 Aug 2023

  • Accepted Members

    20 Aug 2023, 09:55 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Piteripad3 has been accepted to the clan.

17 Aug 2023

  • Accepted Members

    17 Aug 2023, 20:16 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player danio103 has been accepted to the clan.

10 Aug 2023

  • Members Left

    10 Aug 2023, 18:41 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Guner_2030 left the clan.

7 Aug 2023

  • Accepted Members

    7 Aug 2023, 18:48 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Guner_2030 has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

  • Accepted Members

    7 Aug 2023, 18:37 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player SNIPERO89 has been accepted to the clan.

4 Jun 2023

  • Accepted Members

    4 Jun 2023, 19:43 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player call_me_rafcio has been accepted to the clan.

12 Feb 2023

  • Members Left

    12 Feb 2023, 18:20 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Abramskyy left the clan.

8 Feb 2023

  • Accepted Members

    8 Feb 2023, 22:25 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _DiaZ_THC has been accepted to the clan.

25 Jan 2023

  • Members Left

    25 Jan 2023, 19:51 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Phantom69PL left the clan.

6 Dec 2022

  • Accepted Members

    6 Dec 2022, 19:22 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Elpoldit0 has been accepted to the clan.

5 Dec 2022

  • Accepted Members

    5 Dec 2022, 18:58 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Phantom69PL has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

24 Nov 2022

  • Accepted Members

    24 Nov 2022, 22:05 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Bartosek36 has been accepted to the clan.

11 Oct 2022

  • Members Left

    11 Oct 2022, 17:31 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _Danio_Le_Danone_ left the clan.

15 Aug 2022

  • Members Left

    15 Aug 2022, 19:31 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player ____LEGO____ left the clan.

5 Aug 2022

  • Members Left

    5 Aug 2022, 18:16 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player czarnarzepa_ left the clan.

18 Jul 2022

  • Accepted Members

    18 Jul 2022, 16:38 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _Nikeereq_ has been accepted to the clan.

17 Jul 2022

  • Accepted Members

    17 Jul 2022, 22:00 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player czarnarzepa_ has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

20 Apr 2022

27 Feb 2022

  • Accepted Members

    27 Feb 2022, 19:28 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player ____LEGO____ has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

26 Feb 2022

  • Members Left

    26 Feb 2022, 12:00 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Niusiek93 left the clan.

25 Feb 2022

  • Members Left

    25 Feb 2022, 19:05 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player morcin74 left the clan.

23 Feb 2022

  • Members Left

    23 Feb 2022, 16:40 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player dragomal left the clan.

  • Members Left

    23 Feb 2022, 16:37 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player uiowerlk left the clan.

20 Feb 2022

  • Members Left

    20 Feb 2022, 15:54 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player vGeTa left the clan.

8 Feb 2022

  • Accepted Members

    8 Feb 2022, 17:14 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player dragomal has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

3 Feb 2022

  • Accepted Members

    3 Feb 2022, 10:11 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Niusiek93 has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

1 Feb 2022

  • Accepted Members

    1 Feb 2022, 17:24 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player morcin74 has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

  • Accepted Members

    1 Feb 2022, 09:09 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player uiowerlk has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

1 Jan 2022

  • Accepted Members

    1 Jan 2022, 14:59 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Looking_For_a_Girlfriend has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

19 Dec 2021

  • Members Left

    19 Dec 2021, 08:59 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player ZX17OC left the clan.

4 Dec 2021

  • Accepted Members

    4 Dec 2021, 19:33 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player vGeTa has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

18 Nov 2021

  • Members Left

    18 Nov 2021, 21:38 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Bolle21 left the clan.

  • Accepted Members

    18 Nov 2021, 19:46 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Bolle21 has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

29 Oct 2021

  • Accepted Members

    29 Oct 2021, 19:59 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _Danio_Le_Danone_ has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

19 Oct 2021

  • Members Left

    19 Oct 2021, 16:58 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player dentol1 left the clan.

18 Oct 2021

  • Members Left

    18 Oct 2021, 19:43 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _OGONIASTY_ left the clan.

17 Oct 2021

  • Members Left

    17 Oct 2021, 13:51 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player SwineqMorskii left the clan.

11 Oct 2021

  • Members Left

    11 Oct 2021, 10:13 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Farmeros left the clan.

16 Sept 2021

  • Accepted Members

    16 Sept 2021, 16:31 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player ZX17OC has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

1 Sept 2021

  • Members Left

    1 Sept 2021, 20:11 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player morcin74 left the clan.

15 Aug 2021

  • Accepted Members

    15 Aug 2021, 19:48 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player SwineqMorskii has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

  • Accepted Members

    15 Aug 2021, 18:57 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Farmeros has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

14 Aug 2021

  • Members Left

    14 Aug 2021, 20:33 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player MrsHunys left the clan.

7 Jul 2021

  • Accepted Members

    7 Jul 2021, 19:25 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player morcin74 has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

15 Jun 2021

  • Accepted Members

    15 Jun 2021, 17:47 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player MrsHunys has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

29 Apr 2021

  • Accepted Members

    29 Apr 2021, 17:59 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player dentol1 has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

29 Jan 2021

  • Members Left

    29 Jan 2021, 12:01 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player messira left the clan.

19 Jan 2021

  • Accepted Members

    19 Jan 2021, 19:55 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player messira has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

2 Jan 2021

7 Dec 2020

  • Accepted Members

    7 Dec 2020, 18:08 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Bitttrich_BongoMajster has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

1 Nov 2020

  • Members Left

    1 Nov 2020, 22:46 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Rix_HRK left the clan.

13 Oct 2020

25 Sept 2020

  • Accepted Members

    25 Sept 2020, 09:34 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Bitttrich_BongoMajster has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

21 Sept 2020

  • Accepted Members

    21 Sept 2020, 18:55 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _OGONIASTY_ has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

17 Sept 2020

  • Accepted Members

    17 Sept 2020, 21:33 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Rix_HRK has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

17 Jul 2020

  • Members Left

    17 Jul 2020, 21:22 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player renamed_515531597 left the clan.

4 Jul 2020

  • Members Left

    4 Jul 2020, 21:10 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player __MR0WA__ left the clan.

20 Jun 2020

  • Members Left

    20 Jun 2020, 14:04 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Kumbeej left the clan.

1 Jun 2020

  • Accepted Members

    1 Jun 2020, 11:46 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player Kumbeej has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

16 May 2020

  • Members Left

    16 May 2020, 06:54 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _kielich left the clan.

4 Apr 2020

  • Accepted Members

    4 Apr 2020, 11:15 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player _kielich has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

31 Mar 2020

  • Accepted Members

    31 Mar 2020, 14:46 UTCMilitary Personnel

    Player renamed_515531597 has been accepted to the clan.

    No longer a member.

A join is exact: Wargaming lists it with the roster. A departure or a change of position is noticed when the roster is next refreshed, so it is shown with the window it happened in — this clan has been followed since 14 Oct 2026. Changes of position are known only from when this site began recording them; earlier ones are not shown. Where a player’s own membership history has been fetched, its exact dates are shown instead, including earlier ones.